From Fig. 1, it is evident that all RV Tauri stars lie between the lines corresponding to Q = 1.5 and 0.5. With
Goldsmith et al. (1987) have reported that the simultaneous optical and near-IR data of AC Her can be fitted by a combination of two blackbodies at 5680 and 1800 K, representing, respectively, the stellar and dust shell temperatures, and suggested that in RV Tauri stars the grain formation is a sporadic phenomenon and not a continuous process. Apparently, they have been influenced by the remark by Gehrz & Woolf (1970) that their data in the 3.5–11 μm region of AC Her indicated a dust temperature of ∼300 K. We find that the K–L colours given by Gehrz (1972), Lloyd Evans (1985) and Goldsmith et al. (1987) are all consistent with each other. Surely, hot dust ( ∼1800 K), if present at the time of observations by Goldsmith et al. (1987), would have affected the K–L colour significantly. AC Her, like other members of its class, is found to execute elongated loops in the (U–B), (B–V) plane (Preston et al. 1963), indicating that significant departure of the stellar continuum from the blackbody is to be expected. Further, their data show only a marginal excess at the near-IR wavelengths. We feel that the case for the existence of hot dust around AC Her and hence for the sporadic grain formation around RV Tauri stars is not strong. In Fig. 3 we find that AC Her and RU Cen lie very close to R Sct which, according to Goldsmith et al. (1987), shows no evidence for the presence of a hot dust envelope.